Skip to navigation
Skip to main content
Skip to footer

To give you the best and most secure online experience possible, our website uses cookies. Continue to use the website if you're happy with this, or find out how to manage cookies.

Tony Levene is a renowned financial journalist, who has previously been a columnist for Guardian Money. He has written several books, including 'Investing for Dummies' and won the ABI Lifetime Achievement award and the Headline Money award.


Pension planning: good news and bad news

Two huge changes in funding our retirement – one planned for years, the other a Budget bolt out of the blue – mean a major pensions rethink.

There's a new compulsion on employers to provide pension contributions to staff. And there's the Budget surprise of new pension freedom. You will soon be able to do what you like with a personal pension pot including, according to one government minister, blowing the lot on a Lamborghini. However, as the car costs over £300,000, and the average sum is £30,000, most won't get further than a wheel or two.

Pension changes are complex - a mix of good, maybe good and bad news. But they are important – a pension can be more than 40 years in construction and last for 30 or more years.

Good news:

Workplace “Auto-enrolment” obliges employees to join although they can then opt out. Employers have to contribute, an incentive to stay in.

So far, just one in ten have quit, but these are from firms employing at least 10,000, organisations probably with good existing pensions and staff communications. The acid test comes when smaller firms have to join. By May 1, those with over 90 staff must set up a plan while the smallest employer has to join by April 2017.

Auto-enrolment currently demands a minimum 2 per cent of earnings – with one per cent from the employer. This rises to 5 per cent in October 2017 and 8 per cent in October 2018 when employees will put in 5 per cent to the employer's 3 per cent.

The scheme only applies to total earnings between £5,772 and £41,865 (for the 2014/15 tax year).

Quotation MarksAlthough the UK has a higher than average state retirement age, others are catching up.Quotation Marks

Good news:

Many people have small sums tied up in personal pensions when their main retirement income will come from elsewhere such as an employer plan. Now up to three amounts up to £10,000 can be cashed in – the old limit was two pots at £2,000. And the total pension savings you can take as a lump sum goes up from £18,000 to £30,000.

Maybe good news:

Overshadowing everything was the surprise abolition of the requirement either to buy an annuity, widely seen as poor value, or enter into a income drawdown strategy, complex, risky and only for the better off. It could be good news as it offers freedom from compulsion or it could be bad news if pensioners spend it on that Italian luxury car. Australia has freedom for two decades but now some argue for a return to compulsory annuities. This is not due to come into force until April 2015, so the debate has only just started. The final rules remain to be published – and no one knows what new ideas insurance companies will present as alternatives to annuities for which demand, according to Barclays Bank, is expected to fall by two thirds.

Bad news:

The better off see maximum pension contributions squeezed. In 2006, you could put up to 100% of earnings into a scheme. Then the ceiling was reduced to £50,000 – and from 6 April, the annual maximum drops to £40,000. On the same date, the “lifetime allowance” - the most you can hold in a plan and qualify for tax benefits falls from £1.5m to £1.25m. Anything over that could attract a 55 per cent tax bill.

Bad news:

The state pension age is going up to 66 (for both women and men) from 2019, affecting those born from 6 December 1953 onwards. And it was due to rise to 67 (for those born after 5 April 1968) in 2034 with a further increase to 68 in 2044 (hitting those born after 5 April 1977).

But now it is planned to accelerate the increase to age 67 so it impacts in 2026 – hitting first those born from 6 April 1960. And no one will be surprised if those born in the 1980s and afterwards have to wait until they are 70 to draw the state pension. We are living longer, starting work later and expecting a higher living standard in retirement. Something has to give.

It's a trend repeated elsewhere. Although the UK has a higher than average state retirement age, others are catching up.

Country Average retirement age
Austria 60.7
Belgium 61.4
Denmark 62.9
France 60.1
Germany 63.5
Hungary 60.5
Ireland 64.9
Italy 61.3
Luxembourg 60.0
Netherlands 63.1
Poland 60.1
Portugal 63.5
Spain 62.9
Sweden 64.2

source: Eurostat

This article was written by Tony Levene and any opinions are his independent view on the economy or political issues.

Partnership card is a trading name of John Lewis Financial Services Limited.
John Lewis Financial Services Limited is incorporated in England with limited liability under Company Number 4645530. Registered Office: 8 Canada Square, London E14 5HQ.

Related articles

There's a new pension plan on the block that will affect an estimated eight million people but the likelihood is that unless you closely read the financial pages, you will have heard little about it.

If you have some spare cash then it is important to consider the many ways to save or invest it with the potential for good returns.

If you aim for a return that is just above average and succeed, then you will have actually beaten many finance professionals.

One of the reasons people may cite for not buying Life Cover is that they can’t afford to, it can seem like an unnecessary expense.

The financial payment provided could make a world of difference to your family.